RRSP vs TFSA vs FHSA, using official CRA differences
Registered retirement savings plans, tax-free savings accounts and first home savings accounts are often described as if they were three colours of the same jar. Official CRA pages treat them as different plans with different room, different deadlines and different tax results. An RRSP contribution is generally deductible within your official deduction limit, growth is usually tax-sheltered while the amount stays in the plan, and a later withdrawal is generally taxable, subject to official programs such as the Home Buyers’ Plan and the Lifelong Learning Plan. A TFSA contribution is not deductible, growth is generally tax-free, and a qualifying withdrawal is generally tax-free, with the withdrawn amount usually returning as room on 1 January of the following year. An FHSA contribution is generally deductible, growth is generally tax-free, and a qualifying withdrawal to buy or build a qualifying first home is generally tax-free, while a transfer from an RRSP into an FHSA is officially not deductible and still uses FHSA participation room.
Those official differences are the entire point of a comparison. They are not a ranking. Whether a deductible contribution is worth more to you this year than a TFSA contribution depends on official room you actually have, on official eligibility, and on a tax rate that this site will not invent for you. The comparison worksheet will apply a combined marginal rate only if you type one, and it labels that arithmetic as educational. The 2026 tax-savings estimator can instead use official 2026 federal and provincial or territorial rate tables on a taxable income you enter, still without credits or surtaxes, and still without telling you which plan to choose.
Official room and official calendars are not interchangeable
RRSP deduction room follows the official unused-room plus 18% plus cap minus pension-adjustment formula described in the deduction-limit guide, with official 2026 and 2027 dollar limits of $33,810 and $35,390. The official deadline for a 2026-year RRSP deduction is 1 March 2027. TFSA room follows the official four-part formula and the official 2026 dollar limit of $7,000; a 2027 TFSA limit had not been published on the official table on 19 November 2026, and withdrawals generally restore room only on the following 1 January. FHSA official first-year participation room is $8,000 for contributions and RRSP transfers combined, and the official dates page ties a 2026 FHSA deduction to contributions made by 31 December 2026.
Using TFSA room to “top up” an RRSP, or treating FHSA transfers as if they created new RRSP deductions, is not how those official rules work. An RRSP to FHSA transfer uses official FHSA room and is not a new deduction. A TFSA withdrawal that you intend to place in an RRSP still has to fit inside official RRSP deduction room, and the TFSA room from that withdrawal generally does not come back until the next 1 January. Official excess-contribution tax can apply separately to each plan if you ignore that plan’s official room. The excess-contribution guide keeps the official 1% monthly wording, including the RRSP $2,000 cushion for people who were 18 or older, which the official TFSA and FHSA pages we fetched do not copy.
Spouses, ages and first-home conditions
Official RRSP rules allow a contribution to a spouse’s or common-law partner’s plan to use your deduction limit, subject to official attribution and age rules, including the 31 December of the year the recipient turns 71. Official TFSA room is individual. Official FHSA participation is also individual and is tied to official first-time home buyer conditions and a maximum participation period described on official opening and closing pages. This site does not run an eligibility interview for an FHSA, because a missed official condition would be more harmful than a missing questionnaire. Read the official opening and withdrawal pages before you treat an FHSA as a generic third savings account.
Home Buyers’ Plan and Lifelong Learning Plan withdrawals from an RRSP have their own official repayment calendars, which the official registered-plan dates page also lists. They are not the same as a qualifying FHSA withdrawal, and a cancellation payment or a missed official HBP or LLP date is not something a contribution-room calculator can repair. The HBP, LLP and FHSA guide points to those official calendars without pretending they are one program.
How to compare without turning the page into advice
List official room you actually have in each plan, official deadlines that still apply, and whether a contribution would be deductible under official wording. If you want a sense of current-year table tax on a deductible amount, use official 2026 rate tables or a marginal rate you already know, and treat the result as arithmetic, not as a recommendation. Confirm every figure on official CRA pages and on your notice of assessment or issuer records. RoomTally is an independent publisher, not a bank, broker or the CRA, and this comparison is educational only.
Provider links on some pages, where they appear, are official homepages with a sponsored relationship pending tracking IDs; they are not official CRA sources and they are not endorsements of any account. Official government links are never sponsored. If this guide and an official page disagree, follow the official page.
A short official-order checklist before you move money
Confirm official room in the plan you are about to use, then confirm the official deadline that applies to that plan, then confirm official deductibility. For a 2026-year RRSP deduction, official room is on your notice or T1028 and the official deadline is 1 March 2027. For a 2026 FHSA deduction, official first-year room starts at $8,000 and official dates-page wording points to contributions by 31 December 2026. For a TFSA, official 2026 room uses the $7,000 official dollar limit and the official four-part formula, and official withdrawals generally return as room only on the next 1 January. If a step is a transfer from an RRSP to an FHSA, official pages say it uses FHSA room and is not deductible. If a step is a TFSA withdrawal followed by an RRSP contribution, official TFSA room generally does not come back in the same year, and official RRSP room still has to be available. Official excess tax is plan-specific. This checklist is educational, not a recommendation to fund any one plan or any issuer.