Skip to content
RoomTally

RRSP vs TFSA vs FHSA comparison

A free RRSP vs TFSA vs FHSA tool for people in Canada checking official RRSP, TFSA and FHSA contribution room and the 1 March 2027 RRSP deadline. Free, no signup, runs in your browser. Line up official differences in deductibility, tax-sheltered growth and withdrawals, and optionally apply a marginal rate you already know to a deductible amount.

This is not a recommendation of any plan. Eligibility, room, qualifying-home rules and withdrawal tax all depend on your own situation and official pages. Transfers from an RRSP to an FHSA are not deductible.

What this calculator uses

Official CRA pages describe RRSP contributions as generally deductible within your deduction limit, with later withdrawals generally taxable except under special programs such as the Home Buyers’ Plan and the Lifelong Learning Plan. TFSA contributions are not deductible; qualifying withdrawals are generally tax-free and usually return as room on 1 January of the following year. FHSA contributions are generally deductible, growth is generally tax-free, and a qualifying withdrawal to buy or build a qualifying first home is generally tax-free, while transfers from an RRSP into an FHSA are not deductible and still use FHSA participation room. The marginal-rate figure is yours, not an official CRA output. Read the comparison guide.

Official calendars differ as much as official tax treatment. The official 2026-year RRSP deadline is 1 March 2027. Official 2026 FHSA deduction wording on the dates page points to contributions made by 31 December 2026. Official TFSA room is a calendar-year concept, and official withdrawals generally return as room on 1 January of the following year. Mixing those official dates is a common way to miss a deduction or to create an official excess in a different plan than the one you meant to use.

Official room is also not interchangeable. Official RRSP deduction room follows unused room, 18% of prior-year earned income, the official dollar cap and a pension adjustment. Official TFSA room follows the official four-part formula and official yearly dollar limits through 2026; a 2027 TFSA limit had not been published on the official table on 19 November 2026. Official first-year FHSA participation room is $8,000 for contributions and RRSP transfers combined. A transfer from an RRSP to an FHSA officially uses FHSA room and is not a new deduction. A TFSA withdrawal that you later put into an RRSP still needs official RRSP room, and official TFSA room generally does not come back in the same year.

Official excess-contribution tax is plan-specific. Official RRSP pages describe 1% monthly tax above the official limit plus, where official conditions are met, a $2,000 amount for people who were 18 or older. Official TFSA and FHSA excess pages we fetched describe 1% monthly tax without that cushion. This comparison will not recommend a plan, an issuer, or a transfer. Provider homepage links, where they appear, are not official CRA sources.

If you want current-year official table tax on a deductible amount, use the 2026 tax-savings estimator or a marginal rate you already know, and treat either result as arithmetic, not as a recommendation. Official eligibility for an FHSA, official first-home conditions, and official HBP or LLP calendars are separate official topics and are not decided here. Official government links on this page are never sponsored.

Frequently asked questions

Is the RRSP vs TFSA vs FHSA comparison free to use?

Yes. It is a free educational comparison and does not open an account or recommend a plan.

How accurate is the marginal-rate illustration?

The percentage is a rate you type, not an official CRA output. Official deductibility, room and withdrawal rules are summarised from official pages fetched on 19 November 2026.

Who is the comparison worksheet for?

People who want official differences in deductibility, withdrawals and deadlines side by side before they read official CRA pages and their own notices or issuer records.

Sources and further reading